My dad has one nearly exacyly similar but its digital and the numbers are large, bold and amber. it;d be sweet if you did a tf2 variant for the cloak and dagger

Sorry but I just had to do it.
And the answer is phong, refmaps only reflect stuff, not light it like phong.

If you are going to bake normals make it dynamically lit too.

That means no diffuse lighting other then AO and correct specular map.

Css arm? cool

Looks rly sweet. good job would be good idea to port it to css looks sick, now a badass texture and your done. very nice.