FPSBANANA > Pages > FPSB > Documentation

Constructive feedback is an important component in FPSB's submission process. When an author submits work, your feedback on it will influence their future work and their development as an artist.

Unconstructive feedback is counter-productive because it won't help an author improve their work. Remember, negative feedback is not necessarily unconstructive feedback - you can still give negative feedback (and you should, if you don't like something), provided it exhibits constructive qualities.

When delivering feedback to authors, either beginners or experts, you should apply the following qualities of constructive feedback:

Qualities of Constructive Feedback
1. Respectful
e.g I love your work, but with this one i don't like the way you...
2. Insightful and Thought-provoking
e.g This reminds me of Author X's work. You should check him out for more ideas...
3. Honest but polite
e.g I don't like it, sorry. I think the colours are too bright and...
4. Useful practical advice
e.g You can acheive that effect much easier by doing it this way...
5. Elaborated, detailed

Users with feedback consistently demonstrating these qualities will receive comment point level ups. More than anything, constructive feedback is about common sense. Treat artists the way you would like to be treated as an artist.

Qualities of Unconstructive Feedback
1. Negative and elementary
e.g Not very good. (immediate level down)
2. Abusive
e.g You suck, stop skinning. (immediate gag)
3. Disrespectful
e.g I don't like your work.
4. Indifferent, indecisive, confusing
e.g I don't like it but good work.

1st Offence
Comment is trashed. User may be given a comment level down.

2nd Offence
Comment is trashed. User will receive a comment level down and may be gagged.

3rd Offence
Comment is trashed. User will receive a gag. Points may be deducted.

4th Offence
User is permagagged.

Published by tom ::. 2 years ago

Comments

Page of 7 1 2 3 4 ... 5 6 7

	Teh Punisher . Please dl and assess my maps! \| Y2M	x 2
	Posted 16 days ago
I would guess it means muted? gagg someone so they cant speak right? so on here it would be so they cant type
- Please dl and assess my maps!
	Ҝoiyty . Shirt. \| Y2M	x 0
	Posted 1 month ago
WHAT is gagged? Someone out there, please help me, okay? I really need help, and once again, please help me, please?
- Shirt.
	Chabs . Bananite_Chabs \| Y2M	x 0
	Posted 1 month ago
I love your work, but with this one i don't like the way you talk or You suck, stop talking ?? That is the question. =D

	: 5 vicodin chased with a shot of clarity \| Y2M	x 0
	Posted 3 months ago
Sorry, I had to.

	RedArmySLDR . Whats is this sex? \| Y2M	x 0
	Posted 5 months ago
Wow permagag ouchy

	Half_Bak3dM0nkey . You can't win an argument with an idiot \| Y2M	x 0
	Posted 5 months ago
This page basically tells people basic typing etiquette when posting in a community site like FPSBanana. Hopefully these rules help block out most of the spam too.
- You can't win an argument with an idiot
	. \| Y2M	x 0
	Posted 5 months ago
I always like to help people, show to them what might be wrong, and tell them how to fix it :D
-
	ahmedkurd . Bananite \| Y2M	x 0
	Posted 6 months ago
Zm_lila_panic_XL is THE BEST Map :D
- Bananite
	dF\|novalin . Danger Force \| Y2M	x 1
	Posted 6 months ago
I love lamp?
- Danger Force
	MUTINY . Stoked On Being Pumped \| Y2M	x 0
	Posted 6 months ago
Constructive: Hey guys! I love you all so much. You guys are good at what you do. Keep up the smashing good work! XD LOLZ! i got points for this feedback message.. :D yee