Search
Username:
Password:

Register or Reset Password

SUBMISSIONS
GENERATORS
INSTALL HELP
DEVHUB
FOR MAPPERS
HELP WANTED
CLANS
SPONSORS
Exemplary Feedback
The Exemplary Feedback system is a hybrid of the current thumb and former cLvL systems that attempts to encourage detailed, constructive feedback in submissions. A maximum of 5 posts in each submission can become exemplary.
Exemplary
– adjective
1. worthy of imitation; commendable.
2. serving as a model.

The Exemplary Feedback system is a hybrid of the current thumb and former cLvL systems that attempts to encourage detailed, constructive feedback in submissions. A maximum of 5 posts in each submission can become exemplary.

Benefits of Exemplary Feedback
There are a number of benefits to achieving exemplariness:
  • Any assessment by the poster automatically becomes a critic assessment, even if the poster isn't a critic. Critic assessments are separated from other assessments and given greater prominence (but they still count the same).
  • The post is made prominent in the feedback area by a green tick icon.
  • Points are awarded to the poster.
  • The member's EF counter statistic is incremented.

How to attain Exemplariness
You can attain exemplariness by making detailed, honest but polite feedback and testing a submission before assessing it. Don't be afraid to give a hard assessment, as provided your feedback is justified, you have a higher chance of achieving exemplariness and critic status. Moderators should read the Exemplary Feedback ModDoc for guidelines on bestowing exemplariness.

Exemplariness and Critics
There is no automatic relationship between exemplary feedback and critic status. Typically a user is promoted to a critic after they exhibit enough exemplary feedback, but there is no automatic threshold. Critics are promoted manually by moderators (and demoted in the same way).
Published by tom ::. 3 months ago
Comments
Page of 4   1 2 3 4 Next Page
.
What should this say? | Y2M
Posted 6 days ago
I commented a hl2:dm map a while ago when this system was inplace and I never got this for my comment.

I think my comment well deserved one. Here
Jeffers .
F.E.A.R. Enthusiast | Y2M
Posted 6 days ago
Posted by bLackk

I have a question. If a mod make my feedback a "exemplary feedback ". will i see it in my event ?

Yes, it will show up in your events.
bLackk .
Compiler.. | Y2M
Posted 6 days ago
I have a question. If a mod make my feedback a "exemplary feedback ". will i see it in my event ?
.
| Y2M
Posted 10 days ago
I would like to be a Spray Crtitic, because I submit sprays quite frequently and I asses sprays quite frequently and I give good un biased feedback.

Jason_Cooper .
I double-dog dare ya. | Y2M
Posted 14 days ago
Would it be a good idea to allow users to flag feedback for EF? (not their own of course) I just believe that on popular releases, good feedback may get washed away into the far pages, and I don't know how far mods look before going on to the next submission.
- I double-dog dare ya.
PhatMan .
They see Rick Rollin, he's singin... | Y2M
Posted 17 days ago
So is it done by hand, ex. Tom looks thru submissions for what he deems EF?
Kfu .
The n00b Hunter! | Y2M
Posted 27 days ago
I have just received 50 points because of giving an exemplaty feedback!

thanks Tom!

http://www.fpsbanana.com/skins/45503 here is the feedback

thanks again!
.
How can someone draw a blank? | Y2M
Posted 1 month ago
Posted by mach5five

How will you find people that give Exemplary feedback?
I think most of the moderators and admins are the only ones handling this. I don't think there's no one else.
.
Vote for me for MOOM! | Y2M
Posted 1 month ago
How will you find people that give Exemplary feedback?
.
How can someone draw a blank? | Y2M
Posted 1 month ago
I like this idea.

Hmm, I mean it's more like a already-developed idea. But I still like it. :)

Great work, tom.
Page of 4   1 2 3 4 Next Page
Add Comment
You must login or register to access this!
Promote Me
Published by...
::. Super Admin and CS:S Supervisor

[+] Donate
Related Pages
Want more? Find related pages.