THE GAME CUSTOMIZATION NETWORK: FPSB | RTSB | RPGB |
Become awesome - get Ripe | SUBSCRIBE
 
Assessments
Below are the submissions you've assessed and the feedback you provided with your assessment. Your statistics will rebuild daily.
Page of 6   1 2 3 4 ... 5 6 Next Page
Submission Assessment
Skins > Steyr AUG A3
Animations seem bugged, the draw for example when running. The reloads have too much movement in the end and I really don't like the hand movements coming off the mag to the bolt.

Also not to be picky but the lens is off :l
Approved
8.6/10
Sprites > TF2 Old muzzle flashes
Posted by Icepwn

Just asking, no offence but why is this featured? Its a simple texture made into a muzzle flash and it get's featured while there are alot of great skins/models/maps coming out that probably was alot more effort put into, plus this is for HL2?

Im not personally against you or anything i just dont think it should get feutured while alot more great stuff is getting released.

Its a cool muzzle no doubt, but still..

(And again, no offence, just that alot strange stuff has been getting featured lately).

Because it's awesome. This muzzleflash was in the beta versions of TF2 til' they changed them into the gay ones they are now. Yes it's a little cartoony for HL2 but who cares? The fact that he did make an effort to do what no one has done, which is simple yet awesome.
Approved
9.7/10
Models > FN EGLM
I want your babies!!!!!!

Now my setup is perfect for ins :D
Approved
10/10
Models > Xm320!
YES Fucking finally I love you!!!

Next you gotta do the EGLM (whatever it is)..

320 don't work too well with the scar, looks badass though if I do say so myself :3
Free Image Hosting at www.ImageShack.us
Approved
9.3/10
Skins > http://www.fpsbanana.com/skins/65312
Pros: Start off by saying that these are incredible, as a few people have said, really brings the power out of the desert eagle.

The shoot is godlike, aswell as the reload, though the only thing that gets me is the curved fingers when the mag goes in, but that's a personal beef.

Cons: Read above...
Improvements: Nothing at all...
Notes: Nice job, keep it up :D
Approved
9.8/10
Skins > http://www.fpsbanana.com/skins/64452
Not even close to COD4 animations.

First off the origin is too high and to the right, the COD4 Desert Eagle is near center and lower.

The handwrap is also wrong, it's supposed to be cupping the left side of the grip, not the bottom.

The draw is too fast and stiff, not enough 'free movement'.

Desert eagle has alot of firepower, which isn't shown in the firing sequence, it needs to rotate up more and come back. Also you seem to have forgotten the 'snap fps' in your Qc.

The reload is too hasty, the gun doesn't need to move right infront of your face like that. The magout is good, but the magin happens way to fast, unless you're one of the fastest pistol reloaders in the world (And I know we've all seen that video) then you can't put a new mag in this quick. The hand seems to drift back to it's original position before the new mag is put in too, keep it on there so it looks like he actually made an effort to put it in.

Not bad for your first set of animations, keep practicing.
Approved
5.7/10
Skins > http://www.fpsbanana.com/skins/64236
Animation: Hmm where to start...

First off the draw is too stiff, there needs to be more 'free flowing' movement because it seems to just snap back into place.

Origins are very nice, no beef there.

Shooting animation isn't quick enough, seems to me that you didn't use the "SNAP FPS" in the Qc, which you should've done. How can I tell this? The bolt, doesn't move all the way and quick enough, which to me would just get irritating. As ManTuna said, I also noticed that the muzzleflash is off and that the shells are being ejected out of the wrong place. Fix the trigger finger! :P

Reload is pretty nice, gun movements throughout the magin-magout sequence are nice and free flowing, shows force and such. Only thing I don't like is the ending, which you could've easily added a boltpull. NEVER leave more than.. I try to keep at the most.. 15 frames at the end, fast action in the beginning then a calm re-positioning action at the end does not look good.

Overall you did a very nice job, alot better than some of your previous work (no offense). Keep it up you're getting better :)
Model: What is there to say about the model? Lama made it, though it seems to be incorrectly mirrored.
Sound: Sounds don't seem.. 'AK74ish', too powerful for a sub machine gun. One thing I noticed too, there is no sound when the mag is put in, may want to check your Qc or add that sound in.
Texture: Kimono did them :D
Approved
9/10
Skins > http://www.fpsbanana.com/skins/63714
The only good thing about this submission is the model, though when I looked at it it was full of errors and needed alot of fixing up.

The textures, I'm sorry to say, suck. Don't use overlays, or try to just photoskin weapons such as this because you will get bad ratings (Which you already have). Valves default animations aren't the best idea either, the thumb just looks stupid and the fingers wouldn't be curled in like that, they would be spread out.

Also watching the video I nothing that you did a bad linking job on the compile. Watching the movements such as the idle and the slashing, you can see it veer off to the side, or up and down (basically it doesn't stay on the arm).

Seems like a rushed job, next time put more effort into it.
Approved
4.6/10
Skins > Bone 4 Bat
Functionality: Well I can say it's pretty functional, you hit people with it, there for it functions.
Humor: [Insert sexual joke]
Model: Not really the shape of any natural bone, but it's TF2, nothing natural about it.
Originality: Don't think I've seen a bone released on this site, anywhere.
Texture: Textures are what makes this thing sexy. Bumpmaps are awesome, the color doesn't really need to be anything more than white. Unless you wanted to make it bloody and what not.
Approved
10/10
Skins > The Sentry Minigun
Posted by Turkey72

Pros: "i feel alive!"as said by the heavy,makes me feel powerfull
Notes: well,this is a great idea,it is better than any other minigun skin i have seen!

So rate it higher than a 5.

Looks amazing, incredible hack job :D
Approved
10/10
Page of 6   1 2 3 4 ... 5 6 Next Page